Species May Appear Deceptively Resilient to Climate Change
Ecological Air Conditioning Offers Short-Term Protection From a Warming Climate
Nature itself can be the best defense against climate change for many species—at least in the short term¬—according to a study published today in the journal Ecology Letters from the University of California, Davis.
The study found that natural habitats play a vital role in helping other plants and animals resist heat stresses ramping up with climate change—at least until the species they depend on to form those habitats become imperiled. This suggests a need to re-evaluate climate change predictions for many species, including predictions that species in the south will move north with global warming.
The work focused on the rocky shoreline stretching from California’s Channel Islands to Washington’s Olympic National Park, where low tides expose marine species to intense heat. It also has implications for habitats like grasslands and rainforests, which support millions of smaller species.
Waves crash against the rocky shore, which is blanketed with mussel beds at the Bodega Marine Reserve in California. Photo by Laura Jurgens/UC Davis.
Mussel beds serve as natural habitat and “air conditioning” for other species living within them, which can be especially vulnerable to heat at low tides. Photos by Laura Jurgens/UC Davis, photo-illustration by Tom Watts/UC Davis.
Ecological air conditioning
We might take for granted some of the resilience of our ecosystems because we don’t realize how much they depend on these habitats.
– Laura Jurgens
Similar to how trees support birds and chipmunks, species like mussels and seaweed form habitat for other coastal species. They can lower temperatures so much for those other species that there is ultimately no difference in heat stress for sea creatures living in southern California versus northern Washington. If those habitats become suddenly imperiled, however, the species relying on them have little time to adapt.
“We might take for granted some of the resilience of our ecosystems because we don’t realize how much they depend on these habitats,” said lead author Laura Jurgens, who was a PhD candidate at the UC Davis Bodega Marine Laboratory at the time of the study and is currently a postdoctoral researcher with Temple University and Smithsonian Institution. “For creatures that live in mussel beds and seaweed beds, it’s like having a house with air conditioning at low tide. You can tolerate a lot of what goes on outside if you have air conditioning. But if you’re looking at a future with more intense heat waves, and you don’t have air conditioning anymore, you wonder, ‘Where can I go?’ For these species, they could make a big move north, but it won’t help—they still need these habitats to keep the heat in a tolerable range.”
The study indicates that plants and animals whose habitats serve as “ecological air conditioning” are not likely to move until the other species protecting them are threatened. This could make those species more vulnerable to sudden events like warm blobs of ocean water, disease, extreme storms or intense heat waves. These species may appear “deceptively resilient” to climate change until one event takes away their habitats.
Mussel beds line rocks along the shore at Bodega Marine Reserve. These kinds of habitats can be even more important than water temperature for the survival of the creatures that rely on them. Photo by Laura Jurgens/UC Davis.
Habitat more important than latitude for some
If you’re an octopus living in a mussel bed, the most important thing to keep your body temperature survivable is that mussel bed around you, not whether you live in southern California, where it’s warmer, or Washington.
– Laura Jurgens
The study adds to the understanding of how different species respond to climate change. Scientists have observed some plants and animals under climate change are leaving lower latitudes for cooler ones. But this study shows that, for some species, habitat is more important than latitude in protecting them from the effects of climate change.
“If you’re an octopus living in a mussel bed, the most important thing to keep your body temperature survivable is that mussel bed around you, not whether you live in southern California, where it’s warmer, or Washington,” Jurgens said.
The study also reinforces the benefits of habitat conservation. It indicates that destroying habitat can reduce climate resilience, while restoring and conserving habitat can help maintain biodiversity as the climate warms.
“People are really big compared to most organisms on the planet,” Jurgens said. “We’re enormous, and it’s hard for us to understand what it’s like to be in these habitats unless you imagine yourself in a place like a forest you walk into on a hot day. If that temperature is what you need to survive, that forest better be there.”
The study’s second author is Brian Gaylord, a UC Davis professor of evolution and ecology at Bodega Marine Laboratory.
The study was supported with funding from the National Science Foundation.